← All insights

How to evaluate the reliability of a direct debit provider

To judge whether a direct debit provider is reliable, start by confirming which licensed institution actually delivers the regulated payment service and…

How to evaluate the reliability of a direct debit provider

To judge whether a direct debit provider is reliable, start by confirming which licensed institution actually delivers the regulated payment service and whether the FCA Financial Services Register shows it as authorised (1). Then check that the provider meets the obligations the EPC SEPA Direct Debit Core Rulebook places on a Creditor PSP, and how it handles returned and refunded collections (2). The FS Register lists all firms and individuals involved with regulated activities that the FCA has currently or previously approved, which is a record of approval and not a measure of how well a provider collects payments (1).

How do I check that a direct debit provider is properly authorised and regulated before I sign?

In the UK, nearly all financial service activities must be authorised or registered by the FCA, so check a provider's authorisation status before you sign (1). The Register also lists firms that have been reported as providing regulated products without the correct authorisation, so check for that flag as well.

If the provider operates as an appointed representative, check with the principal if you have concerns, because if the representative has gone beyond the activities the principal has allowed, you may not be protected by the Financial Ombudsman Service or the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (1). Ask the principal to confirm which activities the representative may carry out. Finally, ask how the provider meets the FCA's guidance in the Payment Services and Electronic Money Approach Document, which the FCA says reflects safeguarding rules and monthly returns in its May 2026 version (4).

What does the SEPA Direct Debit Core Rulebook require of a provider, and how can I test a provider against it?

According to the European Payments Council, the 2025 SDD Core rulebook version 1.2 is the version currently in effect (5). Each Participant must comply with it, and it forms a multilateral agreement between the EPC and every Participant (2). To be eligible, a Participant must be licensed in a SEPA country or by an EEA regulator, be able to pay its debts, hold sufficient liquidity and capital, comply with anti-money-laundering and sanctions rules, and maintain operational and risk controls.

A Creditor PSP has further obligations toward you (2). It must enter into an agreement only after applying the principles of Know Your Customer, and ensure that the agreement is consistent with the Rulebook and is complete, unambiguous and enforceable. It must also provide or procure a Creditor Identifier if a prospective Creditor does not have one, monitor its Creditors' use of SEPA Direct Debits, and cease further Collections for a Creditor where it has credible evidence of intent to defraud. Ask the provider to show evidence of each of these, since the Rulebook lists these obligations for a Creditor PSP and for the Creditors it must oblige. A Creditor PSP must also bind its direct debit service providers to legally binding agreements covering every function they perform in connection with the scheme.

What should a provider show me about failed, returned and refunded collections?

Under the Core scheme, a Creditor PSP must pay each Refund or Return to the Debtor PSP regardless of the status of your account or of you as Creditor (2). It then recovers refunded amounts from you under its own arrangements, and the date of that debit is outside the scheme. It may require you to keep your account open after the relationship ends so it can honour refund transactions. If it cannot debit your account, the unpaid amount becomes its credit risk to recover from you, so ask how it recovers refunds and what it requires after termination.

A payer may request a no-questions-asked refund within the eight-week refund period, and may submit a claim for an unauthorised collection not later than 13 months after the debit date of the disputed collection (2).

Checks to Confirm Before Trusting a Payment Provider or Creditor

Check

Rule or source it rests on

How to verify

FCA authorisation

In the UK nearly all financial service activities must be authorised or registered by the FCA.

Search the FS Register, which also lists firms reported as providing regulated services without authorisation.

Appointed representatives

If a representative goes beyond the activities its principal allows, you may not be protected by the Financial Ombudsman Service or the FSCS.

Find contact details on the FS Register and ask the principal to confirm what activities the representative may carry out.

Scheme eligibility

A Participant must be licensed in a SEPA country or by an EEA regulator, be solvent, hold sufficient liquidity and capital, and comply with anti-money-laundering rules.

Ask which licensed Participant is your Creditor PSP and whether it complies with the Rulebook and its implementation guidelines.

Contract terms

The agreement must be complete, unambiguous and enforceable, and make provision for a Creditor moving its account to another Creditor PSP.

Read the agreement for account-move provisions.

Risk information and Creditor Identifier

The Creditor PSP must give adequate risk and rights information before your first collection and provide a Creditor Identifier if you lack one.

Ask for the risk information and your Creditor Identifier before the first collection.

Refunds and returns

The Creditor PSP must pay each Refund or Return to the Debtor PSP regardless of the status of the Creditor's account.

Ask how it recovers refunded amounts from your account and whether it requires you to keep the account open after the relationship ends.

Sources

  1. Financial Services Register / FCA, Financial Conduct Authority, 27/04/2016
  2. 2025 SEPA Direct Debit Core Scheme Rulebook, European Payments Council, 30 September 2026
  3. Electronic money and payment services – key publications, Financial Conduct Authority, 05/08/2015
  4. Rulebook and implementation guidelines to implement the SDD Core scheme, European Payments Council, accessed 6 November 2026