← All insights

Direct Debit vs pay-by-bank and open banking

For recurring euro collections, the documented route is SEPA Direct Debit Core, which payment service providers offer to consumers and businesses across Europe.

Direct Debit vs pay-by-bank and open banking

For recurring euro collections, the documented route is SEPA Direct Debit Core, which payment service providers offer to consumers and businesses across Europe (1). In open banking, a variable recurring payment is a series of payments initiated by a payment initiation service provider under a long-held consent (2). Rebeam says that suitability depends on your business model, customer geography, expected volumes and applicable onboarding requirements (3).

Which should a UK business use to collect recurring euro payments: SEPA Direct Debit Core or pay-by-bank/open banking?

Rebeam collects recurring euro revenue through this scheme, and every collection is initiated only after a valid customer mandate (3).

In the delegated-SCA journey, each VRP is processed as a single domestic payment through Faster Payments, with the customer in session for each one (2). That is a UK domestic mechanism, so a UK business that needs euro collections should treat SEPA Direct Debit Core as the supported route and VRP as a different tool.

Rebeam is a commercial payments partner, and regulated payment services are provided directly by the relevant licensed financial institution (3).

How do consent and authorisation differ between a Direct Debit mandate and a VRP consent?

With SEPA Direct Debit Core, your customer gives a mandate authorising collections under agreed terms, so they do not need to initiate a separate bank transfer for every payment (3). Where a payment is initiated by or through the payee, the payer cannot revoke the payment order once consent has been given to the payee to execute the payment transaction (4). Under SEPA Direct Debit Core, a payer may revoke a direct debit payment order at the latest by the end of the business day preceding the day agreed for debiting the funds, without prejudice to refund rights, which qualifies the general rule that a payer cannot revoke once consent has been given to the payee.

The customer authorises a VRP consent with strong customer authentication at their own bank (2). The timing or amount of each payment need not be fixed at setup, but each payment is limited by consent parameters that the bank enforces. Under the delegated-SCA variant, each payment instruction also carries explicit consent that links the amount and the payee.

Direct Debit mandate and pay-by-bank VRP consent, side by side (2)

How a VRP consent is set up and used (2)

The practical difference is who holds the authority: the collecting business under a mandate, or the initiating provider acting within set parameters (2).

Direct Debit mandate and pay-by-bank VRP consent, side by side

Point of comparison

SEPA Direct Debit Core

VRP with delegated SCA

Who starts the payment

The payee, or through the payee, once the payer has consented to the payee

A payment initiation service provider, using a long-held VRP consent

What the customer agrees

A mandate authorising collections under agreed terms, so no separate transfer is needed for every payment

Explicit consent for each payment instruction, linking the amount and the payee

What can stop a payment

The payer may revoke the payment order by the end of the business day before the debit date

The customer's bank must reject a payment outside the consent parameters or after the consent is revoked

How the payment settles

The payee's provider transmits the order so settlement can occur on the agreed due date

A single domestic payment through Faster Payments, with the customer in session

How a VRP consent is set up and used

  1. Agree the consent parameters — The PISP and the customer agree the VRP Consent Parameters. These replace a fixed timing or amount for each payment.
  2. Customer authorises the consent with SCA — The VRP Consent is authorised via Strong Customer Authentication at the customer's bank (ASPSP). The parameters are part of that authorisation.
  3. Payments are instructed under the consent — The PISP instructs each VRP Payment using the long-held consent. The bank does not apply SCA to each payment and enforces the consent parameters.

What happens when a customer wants to stop a payment or get money back under each method?

Under the SEPA framework, a payer has an unconditional right to a refund for direct debits within the EU regulation, within the time limits set by the payment services directive (4). A payer may also revoke a direct debit payment order at the latest by the end of the business day before the agreed debit day, without prejudice to refund rights.

For an unauthorised or incorrectly executed transaction, your customer must notify their provider without undue delay and no later than 13 months after the debit date (4). Collections can also fail or be returned, so your team needs payment-status reporting to see which collections need attention (3).

For VRPs, the customer's bank must reject a payment that falls outside the consent parameters or after the customer has revoked the consent (2). For VRPs, the guideline passage we reviewed requires the customer's bank to reject a payment that falls outside the VRP consent parameters or arrives after the customer has revoked the consent, and it states no refund right for VRP payments.

How does UK Bacs Direct Debit compare with SEPA Direct Debit for a UK-based collector?

A Direct Debit Instruction is an authority from a customer to their provider giving a named organisation permission to collect varying amounts on variable dates that they have agreed. The organisation must notify the customer in advance of any change to the amount or collection date, and under the Direct Debit Guarantee the customer receives a full refund from their provider if an error is made.

Bacs says that under the Direct Debit Scheme Rules, paying payment service providers are required to refund a payer in the event of an error under the Direct Debit Guarantee, and that depending on the error an indemnity claim process may be used. An organisation that becomes a direct submitter of Direct Debit must be sponsored by a Bacs participant provider.

For SEPA direct debits, the payer has an unconditional right to a refund within the time limits laid down in the payment services directive (4). The Bacs indemnity page links to guides that sit behind a Bacs login, so we have not compared Bacs refund periods here.

The delegated-SCA guideline describes a journey that results in a single domestic payment processed via Faster Payments, with the customer in session for each VRP payment, and gives no cost, failure-rate or operational-risk data, so this article does not compare pay-by-bank with Direct Debit on those points (2). This article also does not set out the UK open banking rules on VRP consent duration or liability, because the guideline passages reviewed do not cover them.

Sources

  1. Rulebook and implementation guidelines to implement the SDD Core scheme, European Payments Council, accessed 10 November 2026
  2. VRP Payments with delegated SCA - Open Banking Standards, Open Banking Limited, 18 Mar 2026
  3. www.rebeam.pro
  4. DIRECTIVE (EU) 2015/2366 OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL on payment services in the internal market, amending Directives 2002/65/EC, 2009/110/EC and 2013/36/EU and Regulation (EU) No 1093/2010, and repealing Directive 2007/64/EC, European Union (EUR-Lex), 25 November 2015